Capstone Assessment Rubrics
How Your Capstone Is Evaluated
Use these criteria while you build. Aim for clarity, auditability, and data‑driven decisions.
Model Fidelity & Automation (10)
Link integrity, refresh, and validation
Exceeds
- All sheets linked; no manual plugs
- Macro/button refresh; clean validation dashboard
- Clear documentation of assumptions
Meets
- Statements linked; ≤ 2 manual plugs
- Minor validation warnings addressed
Emerging
- Broken links or manual totals
- Missing validation or major errors
Analytic Insight & Decision Quality (10)
Use sensitivity and scenarios to drive strategy
Exceeds
- Tornado chart ranks top 5 drivers
- Scenario results justify a clear pivot
Meets
- Scenarios present; limited strategic discussion
Emerging
- Calculations present but not interpreted
Documentation & Sourcing (5)
Make your work readable and verifiable
Exceeds
- MLA citations; cell comments on key formulas
- AI/tool usage logged transparently
Meets
- Basic citation list; partial formula notes
Emerging
- Missing citations or opaque formulas
Investor Pitch (10)
Narrative clarity, visuals, and timing
Exceeds
- Compelling story; visuals reinforce numbers
- On-time delivery with confident Q&A
Meets
- Clear flow; minor design or timing issues
Emerging
- Disjointed narrative or off‑time
Peer‑Critique Quality (2)
Help others find root‑cause issues
Exceeds
- Flags root causes; offers specific fixes
Meets
- Accurately identifies surface issues
Emerging
- Minimal or perfunctory feedback